Mini Book Review: Gideon The Ninth (Locked Tomb Tilogy #1), by Tamsyn Muir

A Funny, Necromantic Adventure | Pages: 448 | IG

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

3.5 Stars


Synopsis: Gideon is done with the Ninth house, sick to death of Death, and will do anything to be free. Harrow is a necromancer, daughter of the Ninth House and Gideon hates her. But when the King needs more Lyctors, Harrow is called and she needs a sword – a cavalier.


Gideon The Ninth, by Tamsyn Muir is, undoubtedly, a comical, fun and engaging adventure with witty characters and incredibly magic. However, the prose/narrative did not fit well with the story.

The plot is fantastic and entertaining. Gideon and Harrow end up together in a house along with a necromancer and cavalier from each of the other Houses – the goal? To work out for themselves how to achieve Lyctorhood. This was entertaining particularly as the mystery kicked in and people started dying. It has a very gothic feel. The challenge to Lyctorhood occurs in a large sort of mansion, with multiple locked doors with secrets behind them that will help the necromancers, but each of the challenges are deadly, risking the necromancers and cavalier’s lives for a chance to solve the puzzle. The challenges are an amalgamation of puzles, theorems and battles with giant constructs, each of which pose different difficulties and are entertaining in their own way. However, when the nicest pair of necromancer/cavalier’s dies it pus everyone on edge and the story takes an even darker turn. Harrow, Gideon and some of the other House members try to work out if it was murder or death by challenge, and the more they unravel the mystery the deadlier the game becomes.

The story has a lot of little elements that really pulls it all together and keeps your interest, from the challenges to the mysterious death, to the teacher and skeletons manning the house – everything, even the smallest details, help to form a bigger picture and more engaging story. However, Gideon is left in the dark about a LOT, which means we are as well as the story is told from her POV. Now this is not inherently a bad thing it can be useful in creating suspense and tension but for this particular book and story I think Harrow’s perspective would have been more effective – because she too doesn’t know everything, even when she has her theories. Though, the ending of the book is told well from Gideon’s POV, for reasons I cannot say because spoilers, but it does work particularly well here – so a dual POV may have been more effective.

The characters were equally interesting, funny, distinct and witty. Gideon is sarcastic and explosive, happily throwing out sarcastic retorts when possible and enjoys inappropriate humour, and this made the narrative a lot of fun. Harrow is more cold and distant, dry and her sarcasm is much sharper, but I loved when she had ‘screen’ time and her retorts were just as amusing. There is a large cast of characters all who are dynamic, particularly Cam, Sextus and Dulcinae who play prominent roles, at least to Gideon. But every House member was fun to read about and had a strong personality. The cast has got LGBTQ+ rep, with Gideon being a lesbian, and other side characters are implied to be.

The magic was one of the best parts of the book, the necromancy is incredibly unique. Each house has their own specialisations in different fields of necromancy and can perform different types of magic – which was very interesing to read about. Harrow’s magic was fascinating as she, using bits of bone, could spawn constructs to fight for her. The unique take on necromancy was done very well, had a lot of elements and the magic was cleverly built with a rich system that was complex but easy to understand.

The prose itself was my other issue. The book seems to be a jumble of modern and archaic language and ideas. Gideon at times speaks and thinks in a very modern way using slang that is prevalent in today’s society. But at other times, the book feels more historic, with archaic settings, language and inner thoughts mixed in. This made the prose a little confusing and jarring, pulling me out of the story at times.

Overall, the book is fun, it is a great read that is enjoyable and has a sufficient amount of shock and surprises littered throughout to keep you entertained and engaged. Moreover, the magic will captivate you and you will want to see more of it and the ending will have you clawing for the next book.


9 comments

  1. The very modern style of speech you mentioned is partly why so many people liked the book. I found it grating when I read it, though. I heard so many people rave about it, but I unfortunately didn’t like it much. Are you going to read the sequel?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, I saw some people loved the narrative style, while other (like me) found it jarring. The mix of modern and archaic speech and ideas is what grated on me most. I did like the general story though. I’m not sure – I might give the sequel a go if it happens to be added to my library in the future but i’m not likely to buy it. Are you going to give the sequel a try? 😊

      Liked by 1 person

      • I predicted the end of the story pretty early on, and perhaps that’s why I did not like the ending – I saw how they would become a lyctor, but had a hard time believing that the relationship would support it. (Perhaps I need to believe a bit more in forgiveness. ) I am unlikely to read the next one… but I might read a synopsis!

        Liked by 1 person

  2. […] Mini Book Review: Gideon The Ninth (Locked Tomb Tilogy #1), by Tamsyn Muir – (owned paperback) – ⭐⭐⭐🌟 (3.5 Stars) – A comical and mysterious adventure revolving around necromancy, a house of many challenges, mysterious deaths and a secret route to Lyctorship. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.